• Available from April 23 to August 31

The Greatest of All Time

We’re bringin’ back the best! This 25-pack includes six of our top-favorite flavors from past collections! Includes Double Cookie (made with Oreos & loads of cookie dough), Cotton Candy, gooey Dulce de Leche, Peanut Butter Cup (loaded with Skippy Peanut Butter!), Rainbow Fudge, and fluffy Sugar Cookie Dough!

* Required Fields

$28.00

Select quantity per month

$28.00
$28.00
We’re bringin’ back the best! This 25-pack includes six of our top-favorite flavors from past collections! Includes Double Cookie (made with Oreos & loads of cookie dough), Cotton Candy, gooey Dulce de Leche, Peanut Butter Cup (loaded with Skippy Peanut Butter!), Rainbow Fudge, and fluffy Sugar Cookie Dough!
*Manufactured on equipment that processes products containing peanuts.

Product Details

Double Cookie: Chocolate Cake, stuffed with Cookie Dough, and topped with Cookies & Cream Icing, Cookie Dough, and Chocolate Cookie
Peanut Butter Cup: Chocolate Cake, filled with Peanut Butter, and topped with Chocolate Icing and a Peanut Butter Dollop
Dulce de Leche: White Vanilla Cake, filled with Dulce de Leche, and topped with Dulce de Leche Icing and Dulce de Leche Drizzle
Cotton Candy: Cotton Candy Cake, topped with Pink Vanilla Icing and Pink & Blue Chocolate Drizzle
Rainbow Fudge: Yellow Cake, stuffed with fudge, and topped with Chocolate Icing and Dark Chocolate Rainbow Nonpareil Brittle
Sugar Cookie Dough: Pink Vanilla Cake, topped with Sugar Cookie Icing, Sugar Cookie Dough, and Rainbow Nonpareils

The Greatest of All Time Includes:     5 x Sugar Cookie Dough
    4 x Double Cookie
    4 x Dulce de Leche
    4 x Rainbow Fudge
    4 x Peanut Butter Cup
    4 x Cotton Candy
Serving Suggestion: 4-5 cupcakes/person if our treats are the main dessert. 2-3 cupcakes/person if other desserts are being served.

Freshness and Storage: Our bite-size treats are packaged in clear plastic packs which keeps them safe and fresh for up to 2 weeks when stored in the freezer. Take your treats out of the freezer 20 - 30 minutes prior to serving to defrost.

Shipping and Delivery: Available for nationwide shipping, Manhattan delivery, and in-store pickup!
We ship Monday through Friday for arrival Tuesday through Saturday (unless it’s a FedEx holiday).
Crunch time? Place your order before 2:00PM ET M-F and choose next-day shipping!
Planning ahead? No problem. Orders can be placed up to 30 days in advance!
Visit our FAQ page for additional Shipping Information
*All of our products are made in a bakery that processes peanuts and tree nuts

You may also like

  • The P.S. O.G.

    The P.S. O.G.

  • The Latest & Greatest

    The Latest & Greatest

  • The O.M.G.F.

    The O.M.G.F.

  • The O.G.

    The O.G.

We proudly accept