Pick Your Flavors 25-Pack

Starting from $42.00

SKU

pyf-p25

Rating of this product is 4.95 out of 5 stars

All of your favorite flavors, all in one place! Choose 25 bite-size treats from our ever-changing menu, featuring classic OG cupcakes, seasonal, limited edition, vegan cupcakes & macaron flavors. 25 treats, endless possibilities.

Orders for Pick Your Flavor packs must be placed at least 7 days in advance for NYC/BOS courier delivery and in-store pick up.

Upgrade With Popular Add-Ons

More Options

Looking For Something Curated?

Flavors Breakdown

Tie-Dye Cupcake

Tie-Dye Cake with Vanilla Icing, topped with Rainbow Sugar Crystal
Cookies & Cream Cupcake

Chocolate Cake, filled with Cookies & Cream filling, and topped with Vanilla Icing and Chocolate Cookie
Peanut Butter & Jelly Cupcake

Yellow Cake, stuffed with Grape Jelly and topped with Peanut Butter. Made with Peanut Butter.
Cookie Dough Cupcake

Yellow Cake with Cookie Dough Filling, topped with Chocolate Icing and Cookie Dough
Triple Chocolate Fudge Cupcake

Chocolate Cake, filled with fudge stuffing, and topped with Chocolate Icing and Mini Chocolate Chips
Chocolate Chip Pancake Cupcake

Yellow Pancake Cake, topped with Maple Syrup Icing and Mini Chocolate Chips
Red Velvet Cupcake

Red Velvet Cake, Topped with Cream Cheese Icing and Red Sugar Crystals
Mint Cookie Cupcake

Mint Cake, Stuffed with Fudge, Topped with Mint Cookies & Cream Icing, Mint Cookie Butter & Green Drizzle
Sugar Cookie Cupcake

Available 02/28 to 05/31

White Vanilla Cake, Topped with Sugar Cookie Dough Icing & White Chocolate Rainbow Sprinkle Brittle
Double Chocolate Cookie Dough Cupcake

Available 02/28 to 05/31

Chocolate Cake, Stuffed with Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough, Topped with Chocolate Icing and Chocolate-Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough w/ Purple Chocolate Drizzle
Cookie Butter Cupcake

Available 02/28 to 08/31

Yellow Cake, Stuffed with Biscoff, Topped with Pink Vanilla Icing, Rainbow Sprinkle Streusel & Rainbow Sprinkles
Vanilla Cookies & Cream Cupcake

Available 04/28 to 05/31

Yellow Cake, Stuffed with Golden Cookies & Cream, Topped with Vanilla Icing, Golden Cookie Piece & Rainbow Sprinkles
Chocolate & Sprinkles Cupcake

Available 04/12 to 09/08

Chocolate Cake, Topped with Chocolate Icing & Rainbow Sprinkles
Blondie Cupcake

Available 04/12 to 09/08

Yellow Cake, Stuffed with Dulce de Leche, Topped with Chocolate Icing and Nut Free Blondie & Rainbow Sprinkles
Cookie Butter Brownie Cupcake

Available 04/12 to 09/08

Chocolate Cake, Stuffed with Biscoff, Topped with Cake Batter Icing and Brownie Piece w/ Pink Drizzle
Electric Tie-Dye Cupcake

Available 04/12 to 09/08

Blue, Green, Pink, & Yellow Tie-Dye Cake, Topped with Vanilla Icing, and Blue, Green, Orange, Pink & Yellow Nonpareil White Chocolate Brittle
S'mores Cupcake

Available 04/12 to 09/08

Chocolate Cake, Stuffed with Marshmallow Fluff, Topped with Chocolate Icing and Graham Cracker Piece
Vanilla & Sprinkles Cupcake

Available 04/12 to 09/08

White Vanilla Cake, topped with White Vanilla Icing & Rainbow Sprinkles
Vegan Strawberry Cupcake

Strawberry Cake, Topped with Strawberry Icing & Strawberry Streusel
Vegan Peanut Butter Cupcake

Yellow Cake, Stuffed with Peanut Butter, Topped with Peanut Butter Icing and Salted Peanuts. Includes peanuts.
Vegan Chocolate Vanilla Chip Cupcake

Chocolate Cake, Topped with Vanilla Icing, Rainbow Sprinkles & Mini Chocolate Chips
Vegan Triple Chocolate Chip Cupcake

Chocolate Cake, Stuffed with Fudge, Topped with Chocolate Icing and a HU Gem
Vegan Dark Chocolate Coconut Cupcake

Dark Chocolate Cake, Stuffed with Coconut Butter, Topped with Chocolate Icing and Mini Chocolate Chips & Shredded Coconut. Contains Coconut.
Vegan Maple Cinnamon Bun Cupcake

Maple Cake, Stuffed with Cinnamon, Topped with Cinnamon Bun Icing and Cinnamon.
Sugar Cookie Macaron

Pink & White Shell, filled with Sugar Cookie & Rainbow Nonpareil, topped with Rainbow Nonpareil. Made with Almond Flour.
Double Chocolate Macaron

Dark Chocolate Shell, filled with Chocolate Ganache & Sea Salt, topped with Rainbow Nonpareils. Made with Almond Flour.
Red Velvet Macaron

Red Velvet Shell, filled with Cream Cheese & Chocolate Ganache, topped with Dark Chocolate & Vanilla Drizzle. Made with Almond Flour.
Cookie Dough Macaron

Cookie Dough Shell, filled with Cookie Dough & Chocolate, topped with Dark Chocolate Drizzle. Made with Almond Flour.
Snickerdoodle Macaron

White Shell, filled with Sugar Cookie & Cinnamon, topped with Cinnamon & Sugar. Made with Almond Flour.
Salted Caramel Macaron

Caramel Shell, filled with Dulce de Leche, Chocolate Ganache & Sea Salt, topped with Dark Chocolate Drizzle. Made with Almond Flour.

All of our products are made in a bakery that processes peanuts and tree nuts

Shipping & Delivery

7 Days A Week

Order anytime! For next day-arrival, order Monday - Friday by 2PM ET. Sunday arrivals available in select areas.
Courier Delivery & In-Store Pick Up

Same day cupcake delivery and in-store pick up available, 7 days a week in Manhattan & Boston! (Available at select locations for select products).
Planning ahead?

We make it easy. You can place your order up to 365 days in advance!

Watch the video

Freshness and Storage

Our bite-size treats are packaged in custom-made, clamshell-like packs that stay safe & fresh for up to 2 weeks when stored in the freezer, and up to 48 hours room temp when stored in the closed pack. Everything ships fresh & sealed from our bakery to your door, anywhere in the US. Remove from freezer 20 - 30 minutes prior to serving for optimal deliciousness!
Serving Suggestion

We recommend 4-5 treats per person if our treats are the main dessert and 2-3 treats per person if other desserts are being served.