Like a kid in a candy shop! Create your dream assortment with any 25 cupcakes, including original greats, the seasonal collection, and specialty options.
For same day pickup & delivery, order here.
Pick Your Flavors 25-Pack
- Please Pick an Item
Please Pick an Item
Tie-Dye Cupcake
Cookies & Cream Cupcake
Peanut Butter & Jelly Cupcake
Cookie Dough Cupcake
Triple Chocolate Fudge Cupcake
Chocolate Chip Pancake Cupcake
Red Velvet Cupcake
Mint Cookie Cupcake
Blondie Cupcake
Chocolate & Sprinkles Cupcake
Vanilla & Sprinkles Cupcake
Electric Tie-Dye Cupcake
Cookie Butter Brownie Cupcake
S'mores Cupcake
Caramel Cone Cupcake
Chocolate & Vanilla Swirl Cupcake
S'moreo Cupcake
CRUNCH® World Cupcake
Vegan Vanilla & Sprinkles Cupcake
Vegan Chocolate Vanilla Chip Cupcake
Vegan Maple Cinnamon Bun Cupcake
Vegan Triple Chocolate Chip Cupcake
Vegan Dark Chocolate Coconut Cupcake
Vegan Strawberry Cupcake
Happy Birthday Card
Birthday Candles
Father's Day Card
Groovy Birthday Gift Box
Pink Birthday Gift Box
Classic Tie-Dye Gift Box
Congrats Gift Box
Sending Love Gift Box
Thank You Gift Box
Order anytime! For next-day arrival (available Tues–Sat), place your order by 2 PM ET. Sunday delivery is also available in select areas.
Same day cupcake delivery and in-store pick up available, 7 days a week in Manhattan! (Available at select locations for select products).
We make it easy. You can place your order in advance & pick your delivery date!
Overall rating: 4.988417 / 5 from 259 reviews.
The Pick Your Flavors 25-Pack offers a delightful assortment of cupcakes and macarons with great flavors, perfect size, and exceptional customer service. Customers praised the packaging, delivery speed, and the overall experience, making it a fantastic gift option.
Review topics: ["size","quality","variety","flavors","delivery","packaging","gift","order","treat","customer service","bite","service","favorite","chocolate","box","cupcakes","texture","tooth","hit","surprise","ordering","dessert","friend","tie dye","baked","wow","holiday","cake","choice","macarons"].
"I ordered the cupcakes to serve at my daughter‘s graduation party. The order process was super easy. Delivery and packing was great and I could never have imagined they were going to be so delicious. Each and every cupcake was amazing and all my guests raved about them. Everybody loved them and couldn’t stop eating them. I chose about 7 different flavors"
"I’M OFFICIALLY A FAN. Bought these cupcakes a week before my four-year-old’s birthday. It was delivered so quickly. Sooo delicious that his dad and I almost ate it all from him on his birthday. Was just a guest on the site"
"I love being able customize my assortment"
"These cupcake were superb and made my daughters birthday a real memory to cherish!"
"These were the most superb cupcakes for my daughter's birthday and made it a memory to cherish!"
"Ordered these for the first time & just WOW! Packaged very well & the box makes a lovely presentation. The cupcakes are festive & so delicious. I will definitely be back to send them to friends & family and to serve as we celebrate the holidays."
"Omg"
"Absolutely delicious!! Was nervous because they are a little expensive but when they arrived OMG!! Great packaging"
"If I was someone who advertised stores I would give yours top in the world 100 stars thank you"
"I wasn't fully sure what to expect buying cupcakes online but Icm not disappointed. These mini cupcakes are absolutely delicious! The one tiny issue I have is the container they come in doesnt seem to stay closed. But I'm still giving 5 stars because of how good these cupcakes are. Will definitely be getting more."
