love your peanut butter and jelly cupcakes
"all I can say that your peanut butter and jelly cupcakes are so delicious and yummy I love them so much I could eat 100 of them every day if I could"
Pick Your Flavors 50-Pack
Pick Your Flavors 50-Pack
Regular price
$75.00
Regular price
Sale price
$75.00
Unit price
per
Shipping calculated at checkout.
All your favorite flavors in one pack! Choose 50 bite-size treats from our ever-changing menu, including original greats, seasonal, and specialty flavors.
For same day pickup & delivery, order here.
1
Pick Your Flavors Item [HIDDEN FROM USERS]
Don't Skip this Step! Step 1 Pick Your Flavors Item [HIDDEN FROM USERS]. This step is Don't Skip this Step!
0
of
1
0
of
1
$0.00
Pick Your Flavors 50-Pack
- Please Pick an Item
Please Pick an Item
2
Flavors
Don't Skip this Step! Step 2 Flavors. This step is Don't Skip this Step!
0
of
50
0
of
50
$0.00
Tie-Dye Cupcake
Cookies & Cream Cupcake
Peanut Butter & Jelly Cupcake
Cookie Dough Cupcake
Triple Chocolate Fudge Cupcake
Chocolate Chip Pancake Cupcake
Red Velvet Cupcake
Mint Cookie Cupcake
Pumpkin Spice Cupcake
Chocolate Cookie Cheesecake Cupcake
Blonde Cookie Dough Cupcake
Eyeball Cupcake
Green Goblin Cupcake
Bear-ied Alive Cupcake
Fudge Brownie Cupcake
Spooky Tie-Dye Cupcake
Chocolate Raspberry Cupcake
Caramel Apple Pie Cupcake
Chocolate Red Velvet Crunch
Maple Cinnamon Cupcake
Midnight Munchies Cupcake
Vegan Vanilla & Sprinkles Cupcake
Vegan Chocolate Vanilla Chip Cupcake
Vegan Triple Chocolate Chip Cupcake
Vegan Dark Chocolate Coconut Cupcake
Vegan Maple Cinnamon Bun Cupcake
Vegan Strawberry Cupcake
3
COMPLETE YOUR GIFT...
optional Step 3 COMPLETE YOUR GIFT.... This step is optional
0
of
1
0
of
1
$0.00
Happy Birthday Card
Birthday Candles
Groovy Birthday Gift Box
Congrats Gift Box
Sending Love Gift Box
Thank You Gift Box
Subtotal
$0.00
Discount
Savings
You have saved
Total
$0.00
FLAVOR BREAKDOWN
SHIPPING & DELIVERY
-
7 Days A Week
Order anytime! For next-day arrival (available Tues–Sat), place your order by 2 PM ET. Sunday delivery is also available in select areas.
-
Courier Delivery & In-Store Pick Up
Same day cupcake delivery and in-store pick up available, 7 days a week in Manhattan! (Available at select locations for select products).
-
Planning ahead?
We make it easy. You can place your order in advance & pick your delivery date!
Overall rating: 5.0 / 5 from 57 reviews.
AI Generated Review Summary
Customers love the Pick Your Flavors 50-Pack for its perfect size treats, delicious flavors, and fresh texture. The order process is highly appreciated, making it a favorite for dessert tables. The variety of flavors, including vegan options and macarons, adds to its appeal.
Summary topics
- Treat Size (20%): A significant number of customers brought up that the size of the treats is perfect and amazing.
- Treat Freshness (10%): It was highlighted by customers that the treat is the best sweet treat, fresh.
- Quick Bite (8%): It was observed by customers that these were the perfect quick bites for a dessert table for a rehearsal dinner.
- Flavor Variety (18%): Many customers stated that the flavors of the cupcakes were delicious and the texture of the cake was perfect.
Review topics: ["size","bite","gift","flavors","packaging","variety","treat","order","favorite","cupcakes","peanut butter","family","cake"].
Review highlights
- "All the flavors are unique and delicious but the chocolate flavors are just amazing." —
- "Perfect size and the flavors were amazing." —
- "Wonderful little bites" —
Reviews
I bought these for
"I bought these for my daughter in sleepaway camp. It got there quickly and all in one piece"
Wonderful little bites
"Perfect size for a get together. Moist -!; flavorful. Highly recommend."
Just The Right Touch
"Buy these every year for the past 4 years for my daughters birthday. She rather have these than a big cake. Even with us living down south our tradition doesn’t change and the delicious cupcakes don’t make it two days. Always gets here in a pink box and in perfect condition. Red Velvet is soo delicious and tye-dye and cookie dough are her favorite."
These were a hit
"These were a hit at my sons 18th birthday party! They were just a tad bit smaller than I expected"
My New Favorite Order
"Great way to get all the flavors I love and try out a few new ones."
The vegan cupcakes were
"The vegan cupcakes were too dry and did not take good. Wish there was a non vegan strawberry. My favorites were peanut butter fluff cupcake and sugar cookie macaron. Not happy that peanut butter fluff is limited time. Peanut butter and jelly cupcake would also taste better if the cake was peanut butter and not vanilla. Over all the cupcakes were delicious. I ate all 50 cupcakes and macarons in 4 days. Once you start eating them"
Tasty Little Treats
"These little cupcakes are always a crowd pleaser and are the perfect size for kiddos. My one recommendation is that BbM put extra cooling material in the boxes for delivery to very hot climates. I grabbed the box immediately when delivered and the ice packs were almost warm even though there was no delay in the shipping."
Literally every single cupcake
"Literally every single cupcake was SO tasty!! im not even a big sweets lover"
Ive ordered these cupcakes
"I've ordered these cupcakes many times for myself and a gifts"